COMPARE
The5%ers vs TradeDay: Full Comparison
A side-by-side comparison of The5%ers and TradeDay built from our normalised 31-firm dataset. Every figure was read off the firms’ own pages, and each row carries its source and check date. Where we could not verify something we mark it “not verified” rather than leaving it blank.
Key findings
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Lowest entry fee ($19 vs $59).
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Max profit split (100% vs 90%).
- TradeDay comes out ahead on Profit target (6% vs 10%).
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Min trading days (3 days vs 5 days).
- TradeDay comes out ahead on Payout cycle (0 days vs 14 days).
- The5%ers holds the higher Trustpilot rating (4.7 (35,564) vs 4.6 (1,417)).
Terms compared
| Item | The5%ers | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Evaluation model | Multiple models | 1-step |
| Lowest entry fee | $19 Better | $59 |
| Max profit split | 100% Better | 90% |
| Profit target | 10% | 6% Better |
| Daily loss limit The two firms calculate drawdown differently, so the percentages are not directly comparable. | 5% | None |
| Max drawdown The two firms calculate drawdown differently, so the percentages are not directly comparable. | 10% | 4% |
| Drawdown type | Static | Mixed |
| Min trading days | 3 days Better | 5 days |
| Payout cycle | 14 days | 0 days Better |
| Payout processing time | Not verified | 1 days |
| Max leverage | 1:100 | Not verified |
| Account sizes | $2,500 / $5,000 / $10,000 / $25,000 / $50,000 / $100,000 | $50,000 / $100,000 / $150,000 |
| Asset classes | forex, indices, crypto, commodities | futures |
| Trustpilot | 4.7 (35,564) Better | 4.6 (1,417) |
| Third-party payout verification | Third-party verified | Third-party verified |
| Recorded rule changes | 2 | 3 |
How the drawdown works
The5%ers uses a static drawdown while TradeDay uses a mixed one. This is one of the most common reasons an account fails: with a trailing drawdown the limit rises with your open profit, so the same headline percentage leaves less real room.
Third-party payout verification
The5%ers
Third-party verified
On-chain settlement was continuing on the check date. The firm’s own payout documentation is not reachable: help.the5ers.com returns HTTP 404, so the terms governing these payouts cannot be read at source. Payout delays reported by third parties in March 2026 could not be confirmed against any first-party statement we could locate.
The5%ers — homepage (no cumulative payout figure published) · 2026-08-05
TradeDay
$10M+ — Third-party verified
The only firm in this set whose independently checkable figure exceeds its own claim. Payout Junction reads $13,394,795 across 11,681 on-chain settlements, most recent 2026-08-04 18:59 UTC, against a homepage claim of "$10M+". Largest single settlement $49,277 (2025-09-12), average $1,147. TradeDay does not cite the tracker.
TradeDay — homepage ("Over $10 million in Verified Payouts") · 2026-08-05
Recorded rule changes
The5%ers
- Observed 2026-08-05 Before: Homepage: "Get qualified by a private equity fund and manage up to $4,000,000". → After: High Stakes program page: "Scaling up to $500,000". The5%ers — High Stakes page (states scaling to $500,000)
- Observed 2026-07-31 Before: An Instant Funding product page was published and sold. → After: the5ers.com/instant-funding/ returns HTTP 404. Separately, the entire help centre at help.the5ers.com returns HTTP 404. The5%ers — Instant Funding page (HTTP 404 on the check date)
TradeDay
- Observed 2026-08-20 Before: Aggregators and our own earlier reading described the split as up to 90%, and the cheapest 50K plan as roughly $62.50/mo under a 50% sale. → After: The live homepage on 2026-08-20 states a staged split — 50/50 below $4,000 net profit, 80/20 above $4,000, and 90/10 only in Funded Live — and prices the 50K Intraday Quick Pay at $59/mo (list $131) with an End-of-Day variant at $79/mo (list $175), under a banner reading 55% OFF. A public promo code TDNEW is displayed site-wide with no stated discount value. TradeDay — homepage plan cards and funded-stage rules
- Effective 2026-07-26 Before: Funded Sim accounts had no consistency objective. Payout caps were $2,000 on a 50K, $2,500 on a 100K and $3,000 on a 150K. → After: A 45% consistency objective applies — no single day may make up more than 45% of total gross profits — and payout caps fall to $1,500 on a 50K, $1,850 on a 100K and $2,250 on a 150K. TradeDay Knowledge Base — Fast Pass Funded Sim Payout Policy
- Effective 2026-05-29 Before: Nine account SKUs across Static, EOD and Intraday types. → After: Two evaluation routes — Quick Pay and Fast Pass — with entry from $62.50 on a 50K account. TradeDay — TradeDay 2.0: The Next Evolution of Prop Trading (29 May 2026)
Which one fits you
What the data says, priority by priority. The decision is yours; we do not give investment advice.
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Lowest entry fee ($19 vs $59).
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Max profit split (100% vs 90%).
- TradeDay comes out ahead on Profit target (6% vs 10%).
- The5%ers comes out ahead on Min trading days (3 days vs 5 days).
- TradeDay comes out ahead on Payout cycle (0 days vs 14 days).
- The5%ers holds the higher Trustpilot rating (4.7 (35,564) vs 4.6 (1,417)).
Check current terms on the official sites
FAQ
- Which is cheaper to start, The5%ers or TradeDay?
- The5%ers is $19 and TradeDay is $59, so The5%ers is the better of the two on Lowest entry fee. This page is an informational comparison, not investment advice. Passing an evaluation is not guaranteed and entry fees may not be refundable.
- Which one pays the higher profit split?
- The5%ers is 100% and TradeDay is 90%, so The5%ers is the better of the two on Max profit split. This page is an informational comparison, not investment advice. Passing an evaluation is not guaranteed and entry fees may not be refundable.
- Which one has the shorter payout cycle?
- The5%ers is 14 days and TradeDay is 0 days, so TradeDay is the better of the two on Payout cycle. This page is an informational comparison, not investment advice. Passing an evaluation is not guaranteed and entry fees may not be refundable.
- Do they calculate drawdown the same way?
- The5%ers uses a static drawdown while TradeDay uses a mixed one. This is one of the most common reasons an account fails: with a trailing drawdown the limit rises with your open profit, so the same headline percentage leaves less real room.
- What do their Trustpilot ratings look like?
- The5%ers: 4.7 (35,564). TradeDay: 4.6 (1,417). Profiles were checked on 2026-07-31. Where Trustpilot has withheld a rating for a guideline breach we publish no score.
Sources
- https://the5ers.com/high-stakes/
- https://the5ers.com/hyper-growth/
- https://the5ers.com/bootcamp/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/payout-policy-and-hub-credit-in-the-high-stakes-program/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/what-is-the-leverage-in-the-high-stakes-program/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/which-trading-platform-do-you-use/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/are-there-any-hidden-fees-or-recurring-fees/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/how-does-scaling-monthly-fixed-payout-work/
- https://the5ers.com/faqs/what-is-hub-credits/
- https://www.trustpilot.com/review/the5ers.com
- https://tradeday.com/
- https://tradeday.com/how-it-works
- https://tradeday.freshdesk.com/en/support/solutions/articles/103000335937-payout-policy
- https://www.trustpilot.com/review/tradeday.com
Data currency
Terms data 2026-06-22 / payout verification 2026-08-05 / rule changes 2026-08-22. Prop firm terms change without notice — always confirm on the official site before you buy.
This page is an informational comparison, not investment advice. Passing an evaluation is not guaranteed and entry fees may not be refundable.